- Home
- Television
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Nedliest Catch"
- Home
- Television
- Simpsons
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Nedliest Catch"
Review -- The Simpsons: "The Nedliest Catch"
- By Ariel Ponywether
- Published 05/29/2011
- Animation
- Unrated
Ariel Ponywether
Ariel Ponywether has been a fan of The Simpsons since the first time Bart was ten.
View all articles by Ariel PonywetherKredit Kookies: Flyby: Princess Penelope.And there are no further credits, as we immediately begin the episode.
After a disastrous assembly that concludes with her smacking Bart Simpson, Edna Krabapple is sentenced to a school-board mandated purgatory while waiting to see if she’ll have her license revoked.Bart tries to spring her from the class, but when the fire escape crumples mid-escape, he abandons her to be caught by Ned Flanders.Ned and Edna embark on a relationship that turns out to be solid and mutually beneficial, but when Edna gives Ned a backbone Homer and Bart plot to break the twosome up.
Here’s the good part – the Edna/Ned part of the storyline is surprisingly touching and enjoyable.The characters are incongruous but work due to both character’s general senses of decency.Homer and Bart’s decisions to remove Edna from Ned’s life also makes sense, and I love that the main conflict of the story arises from actual differences in their makeups.
The event that draws the biggest question mark and the biggest facepalm within the episode is the show letting the audience decide the fate of the twosome.This has led to a viral marketing blitz and a grasp at interactivity that the show rarely if ever has had, but it’s also a creatively cowardly and severely bankrupt choice.The show should have just pulled the trigger on the pairing without asking the public; after all, it never asked us how we felt about Skinner and Krabapple, but managed to run that relationship aground as well.
Overall, this is one of the top episodes of the season, an excellent watch.
Letter Grade: A
To vote in the Nedna Poll, head to thesimpsons.com/nedna/
Spread The Word
Related Articles
- Movie Review - Ghost Rider: The Spirit Of Vengeance (2012)
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The D'Oh-cial Network"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Falcon and the D'Oh Man"
- Music Review: Born This Way by Lady Gaga (2011)
- Movie Review: X-Men - First Class (2011)
- Review -- The Simpsons: "500 Keys"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Homer Scissorhands"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Real Housewives of Fat Tony"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Great Simpsina"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Love is a Many-Strangled Thing"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "A Midsummer's Nice Dream"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Scorpion's Tale"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Angry Dad: The Movie"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Blue and the Grey"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Homer The Father"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Flaming Moe"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Moms I'd Like To Forget"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Donnie Fatso"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Fight Before Christmas"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "How Munched Is That Birdie In The Window?"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "The Fool Monty"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Lisa Simpson, This Isn't Your Life"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Treehouse of Horror XXI"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "MoneyBart"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Loan-A-Lisa"
- Review -- The Simpsons: "Elementary School Musical"
