Thematic Consistency Rules as Terminators go Pretzel
This week on Terminator: the Sarah Connor Chronicles, there was
ballerina on contortionist Terminator action, Derek ran into a friend,
and practically everyone got therapy. Not that it helped. (spoilers)
I generally don't comment on the quality of the writing or acting on
Sarah Connor, because I leave every episode amazed at the thematic
coherency of the series and the intense hum of the acting. I want to
sound neither like a hiss and scratch broken record or someone's too
perfect iTune set on permanent loop. However, this week's episode was
simply amazing.
Following "Goodbye to All That" where we were reminded that Derek was
once a child, in "The Tower is Tall, but the Fall is Short" we are
reminded that all the adult characters were once children. With the
benefit of future perspective, we see current children, both John and
the Turk, as the reflections of the wounded adults that they will one
day become. The title itself is evocative and reminds me of the Tower
card in the tarot. In some decks, the Tower card shows a a tower struck
by lightening and two figures fall from the tower. It's symbolic of
sudden uncomfortable changes, revelation, disillusion, disruption and
realization.
In the return of the S1 style voice over, which I always loved, we are
told that Sarah Connor was once a child and her father fought in a war.
This sets the theme of the episode. Her father had his "Goodbye to all
that" and was forever after one of the walking wounded. She never
expected to become her father. Yet there they are, breaking into the
office of a psychiatrist, Boyd Sherman, trying to discover why his name
was on the written on the wall by the future resistance fighter.
The discussion in the car later illustrates the fragmented dualistic
nature of the episode. Sarah, John, and Cameron talk about how they do
not know if the writing on the wall means that Dr. Sherman is friend or
foe. Cameron, ever literal, tells John that Dr. Sherman is not their
friend. However, as John tries to define whatever word covers someone
who is the opposite of foe, the only word Cameron can provide is
friend. Throughout the episode, characters talk about each other in
this manner. In a later scene, Derek describes John's difficulties as a
result of being neither child nor adult, neither soldier nor civilian.
There is a tension between the implied transitions from blank slate
child to a broken slate adult, but we are given no third options. A
page is either blank or it is written upon, and no amount of erasing
can regain the unwritten potential of the page.
The awkward family scene in the car transitions to an awkward scene
with Catherine Weaver. She is doing some sort of corporate/lifestyle
photo shoot where she is, of course, perfect at moving at the
photographer's instructions. However, she cannot smile with genuine
emotion. For a T1001 infiltrator, she's curiously bad at long term
emotion. She doesn't have the instruction set. Savannah plays at
building something nearby. Savannah not only refuses to join in the
photo shoot, she wets herself at almost being forced to go near her
"new" mommy. This both shows the audience the weight of her fear, and
is the first of many points in the story where blood, grease, water,
urine are referenced in connection to people under emotional pressure.
Catherine's assistant says that old saw about not being able to kill
your kids, which leaves Catherine humorously nonplused, and suggests
that Catherine take Savannah to a miracle worker that she knows. It's
an interesting moment, because I was left to wonder why Catherine
doesn't kill Savannah, who is small, fragile, and untrusting. From the
perspective of the future is Savannah friend or foe?
The episode strongly parallel's the Skynet family with the Connors.
What I find interesting is that the family made up of one human,
Savannah, and two machines, goes to Dr. Sherman for help. Catherine
wants Savannah to be fixed. Possibly, like the other child that she's
growing in the basement with a room of scientists, she wants to
understand her.
While the Connors, made up of two humans and one machine, and minus one
uncle, go to see Dr. Sherman to determine if he's friend or foe. What
they find is someone who is very observant, although he doesn't
understand all the clues that he is given. How can he? He can't
understand Sarah's mistrust of psychiatrists. He doesn’t know that her
last encounter involved a mental institution. Cameron as suffering
Asperger’s is much more likely than Cameron is a machine learning what
it is to exist. While, John's issues are a whole new level of
compression.
We see this as Derek returns home from a six hour “run” and there’s a
gunshot from John’s room. He claims to have misfired while cleaning it.
There’s a burn mark from the metal on this face. There's an interesting
symbolism in John's "accidental" gunshot. A gunshot is a sudden and
violent release of compressed energy that flings-fires something, a
bullet, forward. John struggles throughout the episode for a way for
relief from the pressure of his life.
While having both John and the Weavers at the Dr. Sherman's office at
the same time made for some nice nail-biting excitement, it also served
to play with the parallels with the families. Savannah is Skynet's
sister. She has a sibling that she doesn't know about. Her mother is
not her mother. John's not-sister waits outside listening to his
not-secrets.
Catherine's reaction to Savannah’s earlier untied shoe lace was to tie
it. John's reaction is to teach Savannah a silly mnemonic that shows
her how to tie her own shoe. A mnemonic, that like the one for jammed
guns in the previous episode, he probably learned from his mother.
Dr. Sherman asks Catherine a question that ties into the theme of the
episode, what is her most vivid memory from childhood. Unlike
Skynet/Turk, Catherine had no childhood and she has nothing to offer.
When John gets his session, he has rather more vivid memories, but just
as limited range that he can express them in. He is a soldier, not a
veteran. With the cold precision of either-or language, he identifies
his father as not-a-veteran because Kyle didn't make it out of his war.
John examines the exits when he enters the office. This is both what he
was taught to do, and ties into his longing for escape. Dr. Sherman's
question about John's role in his family is interesting, because John
is not being pressured to become his father. That would be easy. His
father died and now Cameron reads pamphlets on preventing suicide.
Instead John is alive to remember the fight with Sarkasian when his
world shifted into a new season.
Meanwhile, we learn what Derek does with his time. He runs and he sits
in a sunshine park. He has a usual food, but the illusion of normal
breaks when he sees someone he knows. He gives chase and given later
revelations, I wonder how often Jessie, his old lover, runs there. It
seems that John isn't the only one who wants an escape. Jessie tells
Derek that she escaped into the past and describes how John has metal
all around them now. She shows him a burn from when one those machines
"flipped" and took out an entire bunker. Given John as teacher of
mnemonics, I wonder what he's trying to teach that metal. He seems to
do very little without a purpose.
Catherine continues to work on both her children. She watches a video
of the couple that she killed and hears the real Catherine talk about
her most vivid childhood memory. Her father was a butcher and she loved
to draw on the large blank sheets of paper. The dead-Catherine loved
the smell of grease pencil. Generally, when I think of the word grease,
I think of machines with grease being required to keep the gears
spinning. Savannah watches the video and sees her father touching his
pregnant wife, her mother, and correctly interprets this as a hug.
Given the circumstanced, Catherine's rather hesitant touch on
Savannah’s shoulder is creepy in the extreme. While down in the
basement, like some sort of mad relative, the Turk flashes through
images that appear to have no meaning.
As Catherine attempts contact through touch, Sarah contacts a punching
bag with her fists. What follows is an interesting discussion where
John clearly wants to be able to talk to someone, but cannot talk with
his mother. While Sarah is focused on the mission and that odd idea
that within a time travel show, they cannot know when whatever threat
that attacks the good doctor will arrive. My guess will be they'll all
happen this season. The original writing on the wall had a relatively
rapid resolution too.
As in this case, where a Terminator arrives inside a bus and rapidly
defines her intent by killing the sleeping driver and in a subsequent
scene killing Dr. Sherman's receptionist. However, what’s curious about
this is that she is working to replace the current receptionist. If she
wanted to kill Dr. Sherman, all she would have to do would be to go
kill him. Replacing the receptionist implies that she has a
surveillance type of purpose.
Derek arrives home, saying nothing of his own future visitor. He finds
Sarah at her punching bag, punchless. He tells her a story, as these
things always seem to be, about a "friend", who "fought and fought and
fought for his life, and then he just couldn't anymore." So he went
outside to take a leak and tried to shoot himself in the head. In a
system under pressure sort of way, this makes me think of all these
individuals that we're seeing who are being placed in enormous pressure
cooker situations. Eventually something longs for release. Derek
repeats his belief that John saw Sarah kill Sarkasian, and Sarah flash
to that Samson and Delilah battle.
Ellison's plot arc in this episode seems more to about placement than
arc. Catherine sends him on the hunt, but only brings him so far into
her confidence. Where last week, he was introduced to the child, who
Catherine admits to, this week, he is denied access down the elevator
to where Catherine's other child plays. Even as I type that, it's
interesting to consider that Catherine is creating her own parent.
However, her agenda is ambiguous. She doesn't seek out Dr. Sherman with
future knowledge. Yet, both a Terminator and a resistance fighter came
back with knowledge of Dr. Sherman’s importance. I’m left to wonder not
only why she didn’t know who he was, but what her plans actually are.
Instead with no future information, Catherine invites Dr. Sherman to
view the pictures that the Turk displays. He laughs because the Turk is
telling a visual joke, "Why are math books so sad? Because they have so
many problems." He finds it interesting because while it's normal for a
child to start asking questions at age 3 or 4, humor is more complex.
What I find interesting is that the Turk either came up with that joke
on its own or it was left in its programming somewhere by Andy Goode,
the good dead father. It's one thing to hear a joke, find it to be
funny and repeat it. There's a whole additional level of complexity
involved in creating humor.
While Catherine seeks therapy for the child-father. Sarah listens to
her savior-son talk to his therapist. The expression on her face as she
listens to him, accurately, describe her as wanting him to be afraid in
so he’ll stay alive was beautifully painful.
Derek returns to his past-future connection and asks Jesse if she
remembers when they met, the day he tried to kill himself. Then they do
the opposite and fall on each other seeking the little-death. As they
strip, we see the myriad of scars and tattoos that mark their bodies.
The wounds they've been given and the markings they've given
themselves. Afterwards, Jesse asks if there is word for that they have
just done, but in a lovely turn of phrase, she doesn't want any of the
old words. She wants a new fresh word for the new-still innocent world
that they are now living in. She has returned to the place of her
nostalgia and she wants a word representing that. She errands Derek to
get her a drink, while she hides photos of Derek and John under the
bed. Whether she is a betrayer or another guardian remains to be seen.
John still looking for non-fatal release, returns to see Dr. Sherman
and removes the listening device, a move which interestingly may have
saved his life. As he tells Dr. Sherman a version of the story of
Sarkasian's attack on their house, Cameron arrives in the building at
the same time as the other Terminator. Something in their movement
gives them away to each other and they go into a rather beautiful
elevator to fight. They are briefly and very humorously interrupted by
a family with their child. The innocent child notices the womens'
disarray, but their parents are too caught up in not looking at
strangers to notice. The fight resumes resulting in Cameron folding the
other Terminator into a pretzel. ASd she cat-like presents the twisted
thing to the others, they look at the chip, which self destructed to
prevent the machine from being reprogrammed, to prevent John from
reprogramming. Skynet wants its soldiers to belong only to Skynet.
Catherine asks Dr. Sherman to join the team of scientists working with
the Turk and in a move to answer his earlier question, she tells him
the story that human-Catherine told in that video. Except when he asks
what the butcher paper smelled like, she doesn't talk about grease
pencils. She tells him that it smelled like cow’s blood. Catherine the
techy luddite loved the smell of grease. Catherine the liquid machine
posits a love for the smell of a dead living thing.
As we shift into the end of the episode, Sarah voice over a series of
shots. She tells us that in 1678, doctors diagnosed soldiers with
nostalgia, homesickness, a longing for an innocence they could no
longer have. However, once something has been wounded, leaked grease or
blood, even if the injury heals over, the scar remains. The butcher
paper no longer smells like paper, it smells like the thing that it has
been wrapped around. We see Savannah climb into the lap of her parent's
killer. Sarah considers the way in which the wounds of war have bled
her dry, as Derek sits on his bench and looks at the innocent world he
has returned to. Jessie looks at the metal burn from a war she left
behind. However, no matter how beautiful this nostalgia world, she is a
product of a war. Sarah has leaked out and gotten no new drink. She has
"No words of comfort. No words of forgiveness" while her children, both
real and not, consider their wounds. Cameron reads a suicide prevention
brochure while the holding the suicided Terminators chip. John looks at
the bullet hole in his mirror, in the reflection of himself and gets,
“No words at all,” from his mother.
We close on Sarah going to see Dr. Sherman. He's surprised see her
there and she flashbacks to the fight with Sarkasian. We see that John
killed Sarkasian and it's understandable why Sarah has no words at all.
After all the years of pushing/programming John to be a certain
someone, now that he's becoming him, she doesn't know what to do.
In an episode with so many walking war wounded, I think Dr. Sherman may
have his work cut out for him. We’ll have to see if his role is to
teach the Turk not to fight in the war room or we end up with Judgment
Day after all.