Season finale shockers aren't very surprising, but this one worked for me.
This
was an episode that just wasn't gonna work for everybody. If you didn't like
Wilson or Amber or Amber/Wilson, then I suspect "Wilson's Heart" left
you cold. But as it happens, I adore Wilson and I was really starting to like
Amber, and I found a lot to like here.
It
helped that we got a bunch of great performances. Of course Hugh Laurie was
fabulous (that sort of goes without saying, since I'm not sure the man knows
how to do anything less) but everyone else was excellent as well, no matter how
small their parts. Bonus points to Robert Sean Leonard for making me cry at
least three separate times.
It
helped that they surprised me. Even though I suppose I should have seen it
coming, I didn't think they were really going to let Amber die, and from the
moment that House said "No, don't do it" until the end, I was
fighting tears.
Jaded
viewers might not have been affected, but I thought there were some great
twists on the death of a recurring character. For instance, the scene where
Wilson tells Amber what happened, doctor-to-doctor, was beautifully done. No
sugar coating it for the viewers, this was the raw medicine that she deserved
and her reaction made me sob. And the note under the pillow...that was a cruel
touch, but well done.
Overall,
I'm pleased my prediction that I was going to get sick of the Amber/Wilson/House
triangle was wrong, wrong, wrong. It lasted just long enough to make me start
to really like Amber and then the writers shot me through the heart.
I'm
especially glad that the question of whether House and Amber were having an
affair wasn't drawn out for too long. (Long enough for the "Philanderers
Anonymous" quip and some excellent acting by Hugh Laurie, though.) I
didn't buy them having an affair for a minute and if they'd drawn that out, I'd
have gotten bored.
I
didn't get bored at all, though, with the remaining mystery of why Amber was on the bus and what they were going
to do with her. And her reason for being on the bus was so in character. Who
else is House going to call if his keys get confiscated? And Amber trying to
make a nice gesture by coming to get House works too. It might have made him
grateful or it might have pissed him off more...either way, she wins. Perfect
Amber!
And
the medical mystery made for great drama. Okay, protective hypothermia is
apparently
bad
medicine, but it was an excellent setup for the character aspects of
the episode.
The
arguments over how to treat Amber were fascinating, but they were dwarfed by
the shock of House caring too much about the patient and her next-of-kin to
make the right decision about thawing her.
Let
me say that again, because it bears repeating: House
cared too much about Amber and Wilson to make the right decision. I certainly didn't see
that coming.
Foreman
was underused in this episode, but using him to overrule House's decision not
to thaw Amber was absolutely perfect. And that moment where he says "House
is going to kill the patient" to Cuddy made me want to laugh and cry at
the same time. Sure, House is always close to killing a patient, but that's
usually due to his actions, not his inaction.
Cuddy
was her usual awesome self, kicking ass and taking names as necessary. ("He's
the attending, you're the family. Go spend more time with the patient."
Yeah!)
On
the other hand, I'm not entirely sure what to make of the B-plot of Thirteen
(excuse me, Hadley) and her Huntington's. They tried very hard to tie it into Amber's
plot, but it didn't feel right to me. I'm assuming that it will start to make sense
next season. Similarly, it was interesting to get a bit of backstory on Kutner,
but it felt a bit...shoehorned, even more so than Thirteen's dilemma, which at
least we knew about before.
But
I feel certain that next season will have enough room to deal with the fallout
from Amber's death, Thirteen's impending (someday, at least) death, the break
in House and Wilson's love--er, friendship, and whatever other drama the
writers can cook up for us.
Speaking
of the writers, as always, there was some dialogue that I adored (e.g., "Are
you okay?" "Can't really say yes when it's a hallucination asking"
and "As long as I’m risking my life, I might as well be watching a
talkie."), although this wasn't supposed to be a funny episode.
I
loved the hallucinations and the peeks in House's head just as much as I did
last week. I wasn't expecting the last hallucination on the bus, with Amber and
House talking, and it blew me away with that moment of honesty. Even though
House knew he was talking to himself, it seemed as though part of him still
felt as if he were giving Amber something important.
And
what could be more important than House admitting that he doesn't want to wake
up "because it doesn't hurt in here"? Not to mention his admission
that he doesn't want to be miserable and he's afraid Wilson will hate him. What did it cost House to admit those things,
even to himself?
From
the look on Cuddy's face when House woke up to Taub jumping into bed and
hugging his wife to the original ducklings together again (in their old booth),
I loved the episode. (House holding Cuddy's hand? Made me
squeal. Out loud. It's just a good thing my husband is used to me.)
Basically,
even though it had more schmaltz than last week's Shabbat dinner (non-Jews:
look it up), this episode killed me...but in a good way. Even though I know not
everyone will agree, I think it was a fine ending to an interrupted (but
generally good) season.
Thanks
for hanging out with me for the end of this season. I look forward to seeing
you back here again when
House
returns for season 5!